The Substack Phenomenon: A Creator’s Guide

The digital media landscape of the mid-2020s is defined by a structural pivot – a migration from an attention-based economy, predicated on algorithmic aggregation and advertising, to a trust-based economy driven by direct patronage and niche community. At the vanguard of this transition stands Substack. Since its inception in 2017, the platform has evolved from a utilitarian newsletter service into a comprehensive subscription network that challenges the hegemony of legacy social media and traditional publishing houses alike. This report analyzes the Substack ecosystem, traces its trajectory, dissects its economic mechanics, and provides a strategic framework for creators operating within this paradigm.

1. The Architectural Shift in Digital Media

To understand Substack’s position in 2026, you need to interrogate the market failure it was designed to correct. The prevailing internet model of the 2010s – dominated by Facebook, Google, and Twitter (now X) – monetized user behavior through surveillance capitalism. Content became a vessel for ad delivery, which incentivized high-frequency, low-fidelity engagement. The feed replaced the publication, and the creator was commoditized.¹ Substack’s founders – Chris Best, Jairaj Sethi, and Hamish McKenzie – argued the opposite: value sits in the direct relationship between a writer and a reader, and readers will pay for high-quality, quiet, finite content delivered to a space they own – their inbox.²

This divergence produced a durable economic engine. By unbundling the writer from the newsroom and the creator from the algorithm, Substack enabled the rise of the sovereign creator – individuals who operate as integrated media companies. The platform now supports text, podcasting, video, and live streaming, anchored by the stable protocol of email.

The Historical Timeline: From Utility to Network (2017 – 2026)

The evolution of Substack can be delineated into four epochs, each marking an expansion of ambition and capability.

The Infrastructure Phase (2017 – 2019)

Substack launched on October 16, 2017, with a minimalist value proposition: a simple tool that combined a website, an email newsletter, a payment system (via Stripe), and a membership database.² Inspired by the success of Ben Thompson’s Stratechery, the founders aimed to democratize the Stratechery model for non-technical writers. During this period, the platform was primarily a utility. There was no Substack network – writers were expected to bring their audience from Twitter or other platforms. The focus was on removing setup friction. Early milestones included podcast support in 2019, which signaled intent to move beyond text, and the implementation of discussion threads to foster reader-to-reader interaction.³

The Talent Acquisition Phase (2020 – 2021)

The onset of the COVID-19 pandemic accelerated the shift toward independent media. Recognizing the fragility of ad-supported journalism, Substack pursued an aggressive talent acquisition strategy. This era was defined by the Substack Pro program, where the company offered substantial advances – effectively risk-free salaries – to high-profile journalists to leave institutions like The New York Times, Vox, and The Guardian.⁵ This controversial tactic validated the platform’s economic viability. It demonstrated that individual writers could command audiences and revenues that competed with legacy media brands. By November 2021, the platform reported over 500,000 paying subscribers and millions in revenue for writers.³

The Network Phase (2022 – 2023)

The most consequential pivot occurred in 2022 with the introduction of the Recommendation Network.⁶ Historically, newsletters faced a discovery problem – unlike social media, email offered no built-in viral loop. Substack addressed this by allowing writers to recommend one another. When a reader subscribed to Newsletter A, they were prompted to subscribe to Newsletter B and C. This changed platform dynamics, converting isolated silos into a collaborative ecosystem. This period also saw the launch of the Substack mobile app, the Reader, and video features in early 2022.³ The launch of Substack Notes in April 2023⁸ completed this transition by adding a town square for short-form content that rivaled Twitter and triggered a public clash with Elon Musk.⁹

The Multimedia & Enterprise Phase (2024 – 2026)

By 2025, Substack had matured into a super-app for culture. The roadmap emphasized a deeper multimedia experience with live video, advanced podcasting tools integrated with Spotify, and enterprise features for larger publishers.⁷ The platform expanded its toolset to include mobile video publishing, AI-enhanced discovery (without AI-generated writing), and more sophisticated analytics to support multi-person newsrooms.¹² The narrative shifted from escaping the newsroom to building the next generation of newsrooms.

2. Substack vs. The Social Web – A Comparative Analysis

The distinction between Substack and traditional social media is not just functional. It is economic and structural. Understanding these differences helps creators decide where to allocate their digital capital.

The Economic Model: Attention Extraction vs. Value Exchange

Traditional social media platforms (Facebook, TikTok, X) operate on an attention-extraction model. The user is the product, and the advertiser is the customer. The algorithmic objective is to maximize time on device to serve more ads. This pushes content toward high-frequency, emotionally charged, often ephemeral stimuli. Creators are compensated through opaque creator funds or ad-revenue shares that fluctuate with CPM rates and algorithmic shifts.¹

Substack operates on direct value exchange. The reader is the customer, and the subscription is the product. Substack takes a flat 10% fee from subscription revenue, which aligns incentives with creator success.¹³ This model rewards depth, retention, and trust. A writer does not need daily virality. They need enduring value that justifies a credit card. The focus moves from capturing attention to earning retention.¹⁴

Distribution Architecture: The Algorithm vs. The SMTP Protocol

Social media distribution is probabilistic. A creator with 100,000 followers has no guarantee any post will reach their audience. Reach is throttled or boosted by a black-box algorithm designed to optimize platform-level metrics, not creator-level connection.

Substack distribution is deterministic, relying on the Simple Mail Transfer Protocol (SMTP). When a post is published, it is delivered to valid subscriber email addresses. Email clients (Gmail, Outlook) can intervene via spam filters or Promotions tabs, but the delivery mechanism remains open and owned by the creator.¹ This audience portability is the platform’s primary moat. A creator can export their email list and Stripe customer IDs and migrate to a competitor like Ghost or Beehiiv while preserving the business.¹⁵ This leverage does not exist on closed platforms like YouTube or Instagram.

Comparative Feature Matrix

The Social Layer: Substack Notes

The introduction of Substack Notes in 2023 bridged the gap between these models. Notes functions as a social feed inside the subscription ecosystem. Unlike Twitter, where the goal is viral reach, the goal of Notes is subscription conversion. The Notes feed prioritizes posts from writers a user subscribes to and recommendations from those writers.⁸ Data from 2025 indicates that for many new writers, Notes has become the primary driver of growth, accounting for over 90% of new subscribers in early-stage publications.¹⁹

3. The Mechanics of the Growth Engine

The Recommendation Network is the defining innovation of Substack’s second act. It has effectively addressed the cold start problem for newsletter writers.

The Recommendation Loop

When a new reader subscribes to a publication, they are presented with a post-subscribe flow suggesting other newsletters to follow. These suggestions are curated by the writer the user just subscribed to. The mechanism is endorsement. If a reader trusts Writer A about macroeconomics, they are more likely to trust Writer A’s recommendation of Writer B about cryptocurrency.

• Reciprocity and cartels: The system rewards collaboration over competition. Writers form informal alliances within niches (for example, History, Fiction, Finance) and cross-promote to share audience flow.
• Algorithmic injection: In addition to manual recommendations, Substack injects algorithmic suggestions based on reading history and overlap of subscriber bases across the platform.⁶

The Impact of Notes on Discovery

Substack Notes acts as the top-of-funnel discovery engine. Before Notes, a writer often generated traffic on Twitter or LinkedIn and funneled it to a landing page – a high-friction process with drop-off. With Notes, discovery happens inside the platform. A user reading a Note can subscribe with a single click without leaving the app. This reduction in friction improves conversion. The restack feature (similar to a retweet) allows established writers to signal boost emerging voices, exposing them to large audiences quickly.¹⁷

Global Metrics and Leaderboards

Leaderboards (for example, Top Paid, Top Culture, Top Finance) act as a self-reinforcing discovery mechanism. Breaking into the top 25 of a category provides a badge of authority and organic traffic from users browsing the directory.²² This gamification encourages paid conversions because ranking is determined by revenue and subscriber velocity, not raw follower counts.

4. Economics and Monetization Strategy

The economics of Substack differs from earlier creator-fund models. It rewards depth of audience connection rather than breadth of reach.

The 1,000 True Fans Mathematics

Substack makes Kevin Kelly’s theory operational. A writer with 1,000 subscribers paying $8/month generates $96,000 in gross annual revenue. After platform fees, this can support a solo operator. This micro-economy allows hyper-niche subjects – such as 18th century clockmaking or supply chain logistics – to sustain full-time professional writers, which is structurally difficult under ad models that demand millions of impressions.⁵

Fee Structure and Take Rate Analysis

The cost of Substack is a recurring debate. The platform charges a 10% commission on paid subscriptions. Stripe charges credit card processing fees (typically 2.9% + 30c), and as of mid-2024, a billing fee of 0.7% was added for new creators.¹³

• Total effective take rate: Creators keep roughly 86 – 87% of gross revenue.
• The tax justification: Supporters frame the 10% fee as a marketing tax that funds subscribers generated by the Recommendation Network. If the network brings in 20% of a writer’s audience, the fee can be justified versus independent acquisition spend.²⁴
• Competitor comparison: Platforms like Ghost charge a flat monthly fee (for example, $25 – $50/month) regardless of revenue. For high earners (for example, $200k/year), Substack’s fee can be materially higher than hosting costs, which encourages churn among top-tier publications while new and mid-tier publications stay for growth features.¹⁵

Pricing Psychology and Tiers

Pricing strategy shapes churn, conversion, and audience quality.

• The floor price: Substack enforces a minimum pricing floor (usually $5/month) to limit a race to the bottom.
• The sweet spot: In 2025, data suggests the optimal price point for serious publications shifted from $5 to $8 – $10/month. Higher prices filter for higher-retention subscribers and reduce churn.¹⁴
• Founding members: This tier lets super-fans pay more than the standard rate (for example, $100 – $300/year). It often converts well because some readers behave as patrons supporting a mission.⁵
• Pledges: The Pledge feature collects commitments from free readers to pay if the writer goes paid. It validates demand before a paywall, reducing launch risk.⁶

5. Hands-On Best Practices for 2026

For a writer launching or optimizing in the current environment, performance depends on an operational playbook, not writing skill alone.

1. The Onboarding Funnel: Mastering the Welcome

The welcome email is a high-leverage asset. Open rates often exceed 80%. It is one of the few moments when a creator has the reader’s full attention.²⁶

• The mistake: Using the default thanks for subscribing template.
• The strategy: Engineer the welcome email to condition the reader:
  • Re-affirm the value proposition: Restate why the newsletter exists and what the reader will get.
  • Curate the archive: Link to 3 – 5 of the strongest posts to create immediate momentum.
  • Solicit a reply: Ask the reader to hit reply with a specific prompt. This signals to email providers that the sender is high priority and reduces the risk of Spam or Promotions placement.²⁶

2. The About Page as a Sales Letter

The About page is the landing page for most traffic. Treat it as a sales letter, not a bio.

• Hero section: Use a clear, benefit-driven headline (for example, “The only newsletter you need to understand the AI economy.”).
• Social proof: Display subscriber counts, testimonials, or logos of publications where the writer has appeared.
• Try before you buy: Embed the most popular post so visitors can sample quality before sharing an email.²⁸
• SEO optimization: Using a custom domain (for example, newsletter.yourname.com) is recommended. On Substack it costs a one-time $50 fee, but it builds domain authority for the writer and supports a professional veneer that improves conversion.³⁰

3. Growth Tactics: The Notes Strategy

Growing on Notes requires a cadence that balances value with promotion.

• The 10-5-1 rule: A proven engagement ratio is 10 interactions (replies or likes on others’ posts), 5 original value-add posts (insights and observations), and 1 promotional post (a link to the newsletter).³¹
• Batching: Many creators batch Notes content. Writing a week of short observations on a Monday supports consistency without daily cognitive load.¹⁷
• Restacking: Sharing other writers’ posts with commentary is a high-leverage relationship tactic and can trigger reciprocal follows or recommendations.²¹

4. Conversion Tactics: The Paywall Cliff

Converting free readers to paid is a craft. One of the most effective tactics is the paywall cliff.

• Mechanism: Publish a post where the first ~30% is free. Use it to outline the problem, provide context, and hook the reader. Place the paywall just before the solution or the deep analysis.
• Psychology: This uses sunk time investment. The reader has committed attention, so the desire for closure reduces purchase friction.³²
• Free previews: Periodically unlock a paid post for the free list to demonstrate the premium tier.³²

6. Multimedia Expansion – Podcasting and Video

Substack has become a viable host for multimedia, offering an alternative to YouTube and dedicated podcast hosts.

The Integrated Podcast Workflow

• Distribution: Episodes published on Substack generate an RSS feed that can be submitted to Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and other directories.³³
• The Open Access partnership: A key development in 2024 was Spotify integration. Creators can gate episodes on Substack (paid subscribers only) while allowing listeners to hear those episodes on Spotify by linking accounts, which reduces player and RSS friction.¹⁰
• Analytics limitations: Substack’s podcast analytics are often criticized as less robust than industry standards (for example, IAB certification). Some podcasters find data on downloads and listener geography insufficient compared with dedicated hosts.³⁵

Video Hosting and Live Streaming

Video on Substack is designed for retention, not viral discovery.

• Native hosting: Writers can upload video directly. Unlike YouTube embeds, native video keeps the reader in the ecosystem.³⁷
• Live streaming: The platform supports live video that can be recorded and posted as an episode, supporting create-once, publish-everywhere workflows for Q&As or live reactions.⁷
• Mobile publishing: By 2025, mobile video publishing tools allowed creators to shoot and upload from the Substack app, mirroring the ease of Stories with the permanence of a post.¹²

7. Case Studies – Success Across Categories

Case studies clarify how different niches use Substack’s features.

Business & Tech: Lenny’s Newsletter

Lenny Rachitsky’s newsletter is a strong example of the knowledge expert model.

• Strategy: Actionable, high-utility advice for product managers, paired with heavy use of community threads for job boards and peer-to-peer advice. This turns a newsletter into a professional network.²²
• Growth: Guest posting and deep dives that became reference material, driving search traffic and referrals.²²

Culture & Politics: The Ankler

The Ankler, led by Richard Rushfield, illustrates the boutique media company model.

• Strategy: Insider analysis that ad-supported trade outlets could not easily publish, given reliance on studio advertising.
• Expansion: Growth from a single writer to a collective using Sections to manage multiple newsletters under one brand umbrella, demonstrating a path from solo blog to small media company.²²

Food & Lifestyle: The Department of Salad

Emily Nunn’s The Department of Salad demonstrates the niche passion model.

• Strategy: A hyper-specific topic captured an underserved audience.
• Monetization: Specificity supports higher conversion because the content is unique and not easily substituted by generic search results.³⁸

8.: Critical Analysis – Controversies and Risks

A comprehensive analysis needs to address significant friction points.

The Nazi Bar Controversy and Content Moderation

In late 2023 and early 2024, Substack faced a defining crisis around content moderation. Reports described newsletters featuring overt neo-Nazi symbols and rhetoric hosted on the platform, which also collected its revenue share.³⁹

• The conflict: The controversy polarized the user base. Free speech absolutists argued Substack should operate like a utility and avoid content policing. Critics, including tech journalist Casey Newton (Platformer), argued that a recommendation network plus a revenue cut makes Substack an active publisher and beneficiary.
• The fallout: Substack initially reiterated a non-interventionist stance,⁴¹ prompting departures by some high-profile publications (including Platformer, which migrated to Ghost). Substack later removed several extremist accounts under existing incitement policies, but the episode clarified platform risk. Writers on Substack can be associated with the company’s brand and political posture.⁴²

The Risk of Lock-In

Substack allows export of email lists and Stripe data, but the social graph is not portable. If a writer leaves, they lose Recommendation Network connections, comment history, and Notes followers. As Substack leans further into social features, the cost of leaving increases – a soft lock-in that complicates the platform’s original promise of independence.¹

9. Future Trends and Strategic Outlook

As the platform matures, several trends define its trajectory.

1. The Rise of the Substack Super-App

Substack is consolidating the media stack. The integration of text, audio, video, and community suggests an ambition to become a WeChat for Western media. The objective is to keep users inside the ecosystem – reading in the morning, listening during commutes, and watching live streams in the evening – tied to a single payment credential.⁷

2. Enterprise and the Newsroom Stack

To reduce churn to Ghost among high-earning publications, Substack has rolled out enterprise features. These include team permissions, expanded branding options, and analytics designed for multi-author publications. The strategy is to move upmarket and serve small media companies, not only solo creators.¹¹

3. AI as a Utility, Not a Creator

Unlike platforms that push generative AI for content creation, Substack positions AI as utility – assisted discovery, audio transcription, and editing tools. The platform frames itself as a sanctuary for human content, arguing that as the web fills with AI-generated slop, the premium on verified human voices will increase.¹¹

The Darling of the creative middle class

Substack has moved from a tool for sending emails to a sovereign economic network for culture. For creators in 2026, it offers a strong combination of ownership (the email list) and discovery (the recommendation network). The model carries risks – especially platform politics and fee structures – but it remains a viable engine for the creative middle class.

Success on Substack is no longer just writing well. It is an operating model: Notes for top-of-funnel awareness, email for retention and trust, podcasts and video for depth, and community features for ongoing engagement. The creators who thrive treat their publication as a direct-to-consumer media startup.

How to begin: Tips for the Hands-On User

• Launch with pledges: Turn on the Pledge feature immediately to validate demand before building a paywall.
• Optimize the welcome: Rewrite the automated email to drive replies and improve deliverability.
• Batch social content: Use the 10-5-1 rule on Notes, batched weekly, to grow without burnout.
• Diversify: Enable the podcast feature, even if only for audio narration of text posts, to capture listeners.
• Price for value: Avoid the $5 floor; aim for $8+ to attract higher-retention subscribers.
• Own the domain: Pay the $50 fee for a custom domain to build long-term SEO equity.
  

  ---

Sources

1. Best Substack Alternatives in 2026: 11 Options to Take Your Newsletters Further, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.emailtooltester.com/en/blog/substack-alternatives/
2. Substack | Platform, Writers, Criticism, & Popular Newsletters – Britannica, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.britannica.com/topic/Substack
3. Substack – Wikipedia, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substack
4. Timeline of Substack, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://timelines.issarice.com/wiki/Timeline_of_Substack
5. Substack Pricing: What You Pay and What You Get – WriteSeen, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://writeseen.com/blog/substack-pricing
6. 10 Must-Know Substack Features for 2025 – Women in Publishing Summit, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://womeninpublishingsummit.com/substack-features/
7. Live video on Substack, one year in, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://on.substack.com/p/live-video-on-substack-one-year-in
8. Everyone can use Substack’s Twitter-like ‘Notes’ feature now | Mashable, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://mashable.com/article/substack-notes-available-twitter
9. Substack Introduces Substack Notes – Geek News Central, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://geeknewscentral.com/2023/04/11/substack-introduces-substack-notes/
10. Spotify and Substack Partner To Bring Even More Podcasts to Listeners, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://newsroom.spotify.com/2024-04-11/spotify-and-substack-partner-to-bring-even-more-podcasts-to-listeners/
11. Public Roadmap for Substack – Reddit, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/Substack/comments/1k086it/public_roadmap_for_substack/
12. Substack introduces mobile video publishing with monetization features – PPC Land, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://ppc.land/substack-introduces-mobile-video-publishing-with-monetization-features/
13. How Much Does Substack Cost Creators In 2026? | beehiiv Blog, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.beehiiv.com/blog/how-much-does-substack-cost
14. Most Substack Pricing Advice Is Wrong – Here’s How & When to Go Paid, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://writebuildscale.substack.com/p/when-to-start-paid-substack
15. The independent Substack alternative with 0% fees – Ghost, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://ghost.org/vs/substack/
16. Substack vs Patreon (2025): Which Platform Is Best for Creators? – YouTube, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=onETtSK5Ak4
17. I Struggled With Substack Notes For Months. Here’s What Finally Worked | by Matt Giaro | Practice in Public | Nov, 2025, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://medium.com/practice-in-public/i-struggled-with-substack-notes-for-months-heres-what-finally-worked-4f67e2246449
18. Should I Pay $50 for Substack’s Custom Domain or Host My Own Website on wordpress? – Reddit, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/Substack/comments/1h77agr/should_i_pay_50_for_substacks_custom_domain_or/
19. Notes for growth, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/Substack/comments/1qazd4f/notes_for_growth/
20. A guide to Substack metrics – Substack, Inc, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://support.substack.com/hc/en-us/articles/5320347155860-A-guide-to-Substack-metrics
21. How To Grow With Substack Notes (When You Hate Writing Notes) | by Matt Giaro – Medium, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://mattgiaro.medium.com/how-to-grow-with-substack-notes-when-you-hate-writing-notes-d54b40f15992
22. Best Business Newsletters on Substack, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://substack.com/top/business
23. How much does Substack cost?, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://support.substack.com/hc/en-us/articles/360037607131-How-much-does-Substack-cost
24. Substack Pricing Review 2025: What It Costs to Run a Newsletter – Sender, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.sender.net/reviews/substack/pricing/
25. What are Substack Pledges?, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://support.substack.com/hc/en-us/articles/11463706473108-What-are-Substack-Pledges
26. 10 Welcome Email examples | subject line & body templates | tips – Kit, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://kit.com/resources/blog/welcome-emails
27. Substack Growth Strategies That Actually Work (2025) – Write – Build – Scale, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://writebuildscale.substack.com/p/substack-growth-strategies
28. Substack Grow: Designing a reader journey – YouTube, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WcT0TV-TlnA
29. How To Build Your Substack Homepage (Step by Step Tutorial) – A Slow Living Path, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://aslowlivingpath.substack.com/p/how-to-build-substack-homepage
30. How Use a Custom Domain with Substack – Really Good Business Ideas, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.reallygoodbusinessideas.com/p/substack-custom-domain
31. How to Use Substack Notes to Grow Your Audience – 13 Simple Strategies – YouTube, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkCwksLWBpA&vl=en-US
32. Strategy to get paid for subscribers : r/Substack – Reddit, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/Substack/comments/1qdcey8/strategy_to_get_paid_for_subscribers/
33. How do I distribute my podcast to apps? – Substack, Inc, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://support.substack.com/hc/en-us/articles/360038462911-How-do-I-distribute-my-podcast-to-apps
34. How can I distribute my paid Substack podcast on Spotify?, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://support.substack.com/hc/en-us/articles/24766453298324-How-can-I-distribute-my-paid-Substack-podcast-on-Spotify
35. Can we trust Substack? The podcast download analytics don’t add up. – Reddit, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/Substack/comments/1oll68c/can_we_trust_substack_the_podcast_download/
36. Podpage vs Substack : r/podcasting – Reddit, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/podcasting/comments/1dldtay/podpage_vs_substack/
37. Guide to video posts on Substack, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://support.substack.com/hc/en-us/articles/21093671091220-Guide-to-video-posts-on-Substack
38. Substack for Food Writers, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://substack.com/food-writers
39. Why are people leaving Substack? – Mashable, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://mashable.com/article/why-are-people-leaving-substack-content-moderation-controversy
40. Substack decision to remove Nazi accounts leads to outcry over censorship, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://freespeechproject.georgetown.edu/tracker-entries/substack-decision-to-remove-nazi-accounts-leads-to-outcry-over-censorship/
41. Substack Cofounder Defends Commercial Relationships with Nazis | TechPolicy.Press, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.techpolicy.press/substack-founder-defends-commercial-relationships-with-nazis/
42. Substack faces user revolt over anti-censorship stance on neo-Nazis – The Guardian, accessed on January 18, 2026, https://www.theguardian.com/media/2024/jan/03/substack-user-revolt-anti-censorship-stance-neo-nazis